Chicago-American for 1903
1 Nick Altrock
2 James J. Callahan
3 J.'Jiggs' Donahue
4 Patrick Flaherty
5 Daniel Green
6 William Holmes
7 Frank Isbell
8 George H. Magoon
9 Frank Owen
10 Roy Patterson
11 John Slattery
12 Lee Tannehill
13 G. Harry White

Chicago-American for 1904
1 August Dundon
2 Frank Smith
3 Edward A. Walsh

Chicago-American for 1905
1 Ernest Vinson

Chicago-American for 1906
1 Patrick Dougherty
2 Edgar Hahn
3 Harry Hart
4 George Rohe
5 Frank Roth

Chicago-American for 1907
1 Charles Hickman

Chicago-American for 1908
1 Frederick Parent

Chicago-American for 1909
0

Chicago-American for 1910
1 Russell Blackburne
2 Harry D. Lord

Chicago-American for 1911
0