Cleveland-American for 1903
1 Harry Bay
2 Harry Bemis
3 William J. Bradley
4 Frank Donahue
5 Elmer Flick
6 William Gochnauer
7 Charles Hickman
8 Adrian Joss
9 John McCarthy
10 Earl Moore
11 R.S.Rhoades
12 John Thoney
13 Eugene Wright

Cleveland-American for 1904
1 Fred Buelow
2 Charles C. Carr
3 Otto Hess
4 William L. Lush
5 George Stovall
6 Terrence Turner

Cleveland-American for 1905
1 Otto Jordan
2 Ernest Vinson

Cleveland-American for 1906
1 J. Barbeau
2 Justin J. Clarke
3 W.M.Congalton
4 Harry Eells
5 James Jackson
6 Claude Rossman
7 John Townsend
8 Howard P. Wilson

Cleveland-American for 1907
1 Charles Berger
2 Walter Clarkson
3 Harry Hinchman
4 William Hinchman
5 George Nill
6 Peter O'Brien

Cleveland-American for 1908
0

Cleveland-American for 1909
1 Denton 'Cy' Young

Cleveland-American for 1910
0

Cleveland-American for 1911
0