New York-American for 1903
1 Walter Beville
2 Jack Chesbro
3 William Conroy
4 Norman Elberfeld
5 John Ganzell
6 Clark Griffith
7 Harry Howell
8 William Keeler
9 Herman Long
10 Herman McFarland
11 John O'Connor
12 Jesse Tannehill
13 James Williams
14 Louis Wiltse

New York-American for 1904
1 John Anderson
2 Patrick Dougherty
3 David L. Fultz
4 Thomas Hughes
5 James McGuire
6 Albert Orth
7 John Powell
8 John Thoney

New York-American for 1905
1 Frank Hahn
2 John Kleinow
3 Ambrose Puttman
4 Joseph Yeager

New York-American for 1906
1 Harold Chase
2 Walter Clarkson
3 Daniel Hoffman
4 William Hogg
5 Robert Keefe
6 Frank Laporte
7 Eugene Moriarty
8 Eustace Newton
9 Ira Thomas

New York-American for 1907
1 Joe Doyle
2 Frank Kitson
3 Earl Moore

New York-American for 1908
0

New York-American for 1909
0

New York-American for 1910
1 James Austin

New York-American for 1911
1 Burde Cree

* Also produced with the Baltimore Orioles as the team.