St Louis-American for 1903
1 Jesse Burkett
2 Frank Donahue
3 William Friel
4 J.E.Heidrick
5 Charles Hemphill
6 Hunter Hill
7 Michael Kahoe
8 Barry McCormick
9 Richard Padden
10 John Powell
11 Edward Siever
12 William Sudhoff
13 Joseph Sugden
14 Eugene Wright

St Louis-American for 1904
1 Frederick Glade
2 Harry Gleason
3 Harry Howell
4 Thomas Jones
5 Charles P. Moran
6 John O'Connor
7 Barney Pelty

St Louis-American for 1905
1 Frank Roth
2 George Stone

St Louis-American for 1906
1 Roy A. Hartzell
2 Harry Jacobson
3 Bernard Koehler
4 James R. McAleer
5 Harry Niles
6 Peter O'Brien
7 Oliver Pickering
8 Edward Smith

St Louis-American for 1907
1 James Delahanty
2 William Dineen
3 Joseph Yeager

St Louis-American for 1908
1 George Edward Waddell

St Louis-American for 1909
0

St Louis-American for 1910
1 William Abstein
2 William Bailey
3 Dode Criss
4 Joseph Lake
5 Al Schweitzer
6 James Stephens

St Louis-American for 1911
0